Signs of the scout mindset are admitting you're wrong, taking honest criticism, and taking precautions to avoid fooling yourself.In reality more knowledgeable people are more politically polarized on contentious scientific issues like climate change. Intelligence and knowledge don't necessarily make you use scout's mindset."More and more, it's a scout's world now." While our soldier mindsets may have been well adapted to the ancestral environment we'd be better off today relying more on the scouts mindset. ![]() We overestimate social costs and how much others judge us and are willing to hurt our long term well being to avoid minor social embarrassment.Since deceiving ourselves has ripple effects and is delayed and unpredictable this is the type of cost we are likely to neglect.We can overuse soldier mindset due to present bias for similar reasons to not going to the gym as often as we should.Not perceiving the world accurately makes us worse at making impactful decisions.We use soldier mindset because it is comforting, motivating, helps convince other people, and improves our self esteem.In scouts mindset finding out you're wrong is a good thing, you've improved your map."If directionally motivated reasoning is like being a soldier fighting off threatening evidence, accuracy motivated reasoning is like being a scout forming a map of the strategic landscape.".Our language has "soldier mindset" built in as we "defend" our ideas from being "shot down".When we engage in motivated reasoning we ask "Can I believe this?" for things we want to believe and "Must I believe this?" for things we don't."Scout mindset: the motivation to see things as they are, not as you wish they were.".More by Scott AlexanderĪ reader has created a web app web that allows SSC readers to place themselves on a map. Regular threadsĪ blog by Scott Alexander about human cognition, politics, and medicine. A user also maintains an unofficial registry of bans. When making a claim that isn't outright obvious, you should proactively provide evidence in proportion to how partisan and inflammatory your claim might be.įeel free to report comments or message the mods with your thoughts. ![]() ![]() Assume the people you're talking to or about have thought through the issues you're discussing, and try to represent their views in a way they would recognize. See the Victorian Sufi Buddha Lite comment policy: comments should be at least two of. Companion subreddit for Slate Star Codex.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |